"There is so much wonderful dining down here, but date night feels incomplete if it isn't dinner and a show," Aden Nepom told The Oregonian this month. She and her husband, Eric, now own 720 Main St. Most people in Oregon City know it as the Pioneer Pub. In 1912 it opened as the Star Theater.
That sale is part of a wider pattern on downtown Main Street this fall. The buildings changing hands are going back to the work they did generations ago. A former movie house is becoming a stage again. A saloon building that once held the city's first grocery plans to pour drinks again and rent rooms upstairs. And a few blocks away, a small grocer has brought daily shopping back to the middle of downtown.
A 300-seat house comes back with about 100 seats
The Star Theater was Oregon City's first. It opened with vaudeville shows and "photoplays," seated 300, and ran until around 1950. After that the building held a string of bars and nightclubs, the Pioneer Pub most recently. The pub closed in February. The Nepoms bought the building in August, and they named their venture First City Theater, a nod to Oregon City's standing as the first incorporated city west of the Rocky Mountains.
The new room will be smaller than the old one. The Oregonian reports plans for tiered seating for about 80 to 100 people and a stage roughly 12 by 26 feet. The building will also get classroom space for improv workshops and rehearsals, plus a green room. The lineup the owners describe covers improv, scripted theater, musicals, burlesque, classic movies and stand-up comedy. Infinite Improv, which Eric founded 25 years ago, will be the resident improv company.
There won't be curtains this holiday season. Eric estimates the renovation will take six months to a year, and he hopes to open with a Star Wars parody play. The theater plans to serve beer, wine and snacks and leave dinner to the restaurants nearby. Progress updates are posted at firstcitytheater.org.
The Star had a bigger sibling. In 1921 its owner, W.A. Long, opened the 750-seat Liberty Theatre half a block away. That building came down in 2004, and the site is now Liberty Plaza. This year's holiday tree goes up on the lot of its old movie palace, half a block from the stage that is on its way back.
The neighbors at 503 and 712 Main
First City Theater won't be the only place for fans of stories on its block. Next door at 712 Main St., Comics Adventure moved to Oregon City in 2026. It stocks comics, manga, graphic novels, Pokémon and Magic cards, and supplies for role-playing and miniature games. The Oregon City Chamber of Commerce scheduled its ribbon-cutting for September 2.
A couple of blocks up the street, 503 Main St. is between tenants. White Rabbit Book Cafe began in 2014 as a small book and gift shop. Danielle and Rolland Walsh moved it to 503 Main in 2017, and it became known for free events like themed trivia, tarot readings and puzzle nights. The Oregonian reported in October that it was closing after 12 years.
The next tenant is Cognitive Surplus, an Oregon company that sells math- and science-themed stationery, apparel and home goods. Kristen and Geoff Zephyrus founded it in 2013 as an online and wholesale business. It opened its first store in Redmond in 2024 and a Portland store at 3508 S.E. Hawthorne St. this summer. Oregon City will be its fifth location and its third in Oregon, and the company is tentatively aiming for February.
Hilary Sueoka, who works in sustainability and outreach for the company, told The Oregonian why they picked this street: "there were already a bunch of fun nerdy spaces so we thought we'd fit in and add to the street in a nice way."
Here are the addresses in one place, with the old jobs next to the new ones:
| Address | Earlier life | What's happening now |
|---|---|---|
| 503 Main St. | White Rabbit Book Cafe, 2017 to fall 2026 | Cognitive Surplus, tentatively February |
| 610 Main St., Suite A | Vacant until late December 2025 | Oregon City Market, opened March 3, 2026 |
| 712 Main St. | Comics Adventure, moved to Oregon City in 2026 | |
| 720 Main St. | Star Theater from 1912, later the Pioneer Pub | First City Theater, renovation estimated at six months to a year |
| 800 Main St. | Liberty Theatre, 1921 to 2004 | Liberty Plaza, site of the Dec. 5 tree lighting |
| 1320 Main St. | Freytag's Grocery in the 1880s, Trail's End Saloon from 1992 | Planned bar, restaurant and four-suite hotel |
Upstairs at 1320 Main, downtown's first rooms
The building at the bottom of that table may change downtown the most. Trail's End Saloon was Oregon City's best-known blues bar for decades. It closed last November, and the two-story, 4,500-square-foot building has been empty since. The Oregonian reported in August that Aviad Tapiro, a West Linn resident who owns the design and construction company Tapiro Group, bought the property in June.
The site goes back further than the saloon. In the 1880s it was Freytag's Grocery, believed to be the city's first grocery store. The current structure went up after a major fire around 1905. In the 1940s it housed a Chinese restaurant, and in 1992 Dan and Jean Montjoy turned it into Trail's End Saloon.
Tapiro wants the ground floor to be a bar and restaurant again, with live music and dancing. He describes a family-friendly place with an Old West theme that celebrates the building's history and Oregon City's role as the end of the Oregon Trail. As of the August report, he was looking for an operator or business partner to run the food and drinks and hoped to reopen the bar within six months.
The upstairs plan matters more for downtown. The second floor once held apartments, and most of them have fallen into disrepair. Tapiro plans to turn the space into a four-suite boutique hotel. According to The Oregonian, Oregon City currently has no overnight lodging along Main Street or anywhere in its downtown core. Four suites would be the first. The project has conditional approval for a $100,000 award from Clackamas County's Tourism Small Business & Entrepreneur Acceleration Grant Program.
Picture the evening the Nepoms describe: dinner downtown, then a show at 720 Main. Rooms at 1320 Main would let visiting relatives stay within walking distance of both.
A grocer in the middle of Main again
Some of the new tenants are already part of daily life downtown. Oregon City Market opened March 3 at 610 Main St., Suite A, with its entrance on 6th Street between Railroad Avenue and Main. Owners Jana Daisy-Ensign and Tim Ensign have lived in Oregon City for nearly 20 years. According to the Oregon City Insider, they opened it after years of watching downtown go without a real grocery option.
The shop has 600 square feet of floor space with Doug fir shelving and big windows. The shelves carry beer, wine and cider, grab-and-go sandwiches, pantry staples, eggs and dairy, some produce from local farms, fresh flowers, tea and locally roasted coffee. On the wall hangs a print from the city archives of an 1800s grocery that stood just feet away.
The market's website says it is open six days a week and posts its current schedule and tasting calendar there. Its wine club ran October orders and pickups.
Saturday, Dec. 5, on Main Street
You can see most of these buildings in one day. Two events fall on the same Saturday:
- Morning to midafternoon, 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. The Pioneer Community Center Holiday Bazaar fills 615 5th St. with more than 50 vendors selling art, crafts, food and vintage goods.
- Afternoon. Walk down to Main. Oregon City Market at 6th and Main is the place for picnic or dinner supplies. Two blocks on, Comics Adventure sits at 712 Main, next door to the future First City Theater.
- Evening, 5 to 7 p.m. The Downtown Oregon City Association's Holiday Tree Lighting takes place at Liberty Plaza, 800 Main St., where the Liberty Theatre stood for more than 80 years.
From Liberty Plaza, 720 Main is half a block back the way you came. And 503 Main, where Cognitive Surplus plans to open in February, is a short walk along the same street.
The theater at 720 Main and the rooms planned for 1320 Main both started with an owner seeing what an old building could be used for again. If you're thinking about the same question for your own place in Oregon City, the counselors at Corcoran Prime are always glad to talk it through. Contact Us.